Inquiry CartInquiry Cart
Home - blog

Comparing PoE Standards: Understanding Power over Ethernet and Power Levels

January 29, 2024

In the realm of network technology, Power over Ethernet (PoE) plays a significant role. This article aims to impart a technical understanding of various PoE standards, focusing on their distinct characteristics, power levels, and applications. The intent is to equip readers with knowledge that enables them to make informed decisions when selecting a PoE standard. We will present a comprehensive comparison without any subjective language or personal opinions, adhering to a strictly professional tone.

What is Power over Ethernet (PoE)?

Power over Ethernet, often shortened as PoE, is a revolutionary technology that allows for the simultaneous transmission of both power and data over a single Ethernet cable. This technology eliminates the need for separate power supplies, simplifying the process of deploying network devices and reducing infrastructure costs. Providing both data connection and electrical power through one cable offers enhanced flexibility and scalability, making PoE a valuable solution for businesses and organizations looking to optimize their network infrastructure.

 

Definition of PoE

Power over Ethernet refers to any of several standardized or ad-hoc systems that pass electrical power along with data on twisted pair Ethernet cabling. This allows a single cable to provide both data connection and electrical power to devices such as wireless access points, IP cameras, and VoIP phones.

 

Application of PoE

PoE finds its application in a wide array of devices and systems. It’s extensively used in IP cameras for surveillance, where it simplifies installation by eliminating the need for separate power cables. In VoIP phones, PoE allows for centralized power backup, ensuring uninterrupted service. Other applications include wireless access points, IoT devices, network switches, and LED lighting systems.

 

PoE Types and Standards

There are three main types of PoE: PoE (IEEE 802.3af), PoE+ (IEEE 802.3at), and PoE++ (IEEE 802.3bt). The original PoE standard provides up to 15.4W of DC power, while PoE+ supports up to 30W, and PoE++ delivers up to 90W. Each standard caters to different power requirements, allowing for a broader range of devices to be powered via PoE.

 

How PoE Works

PoE works by delivering electrical power over the same cable that transmits data signals. It uses two pairs of wires in the Ethernet cable for power and data. The process involves a PoE switch (or injector) that inserts power onto the cable and a powered device that splits the power off from the data, using it to run the device.

 

Advantages and Disadvantages of PoE

Advantages of PoE include simplified installation, reduced infrastructure costs, increased flexibility for device placement, centralized power management, and the ability to support remote device reset and monitoring.

 

However, PoE also has its disadvantages. These include a limited power supply, potential for heat generation in bundled cables, need for specialized equipment such as PoE switches or injectors, and a maximum distance limitation of 100 meters from the power source.

8-port poe powered switch
8-port poe powered switch

Understanding Different PoE Types and Standards

Power over Ethernet (PoE) technology allows for the simultaneous transmission of power and data over an Ethernet cable. This technology comes in various types and standards, each designed to cater to different requirements in terms of power levels and applications. Understanding these variations is essential for network administrators and IT professionals to make informed decisions about their infrastructure.

 

Explaining PoE Types (Type 1, Type 2, Type 3, Type 4)

Power over Ethernet (PoE) technology is classified into different types based on the power levels they provide. The primary types are Type 1, Type 2, Type 3, and Type 4. Understanding these types is essential for network administrators and IT professionals when designing and deploying PoE networks.

 

Type 1 PoE (IEEE 802.3af)

Type 1 PoE, also known as IEEE 802.3af, is the original PoE standard. This standard supports a maximum power output of 15.4W per port, but due to power dissipation in the cable, only about 12.95W can reach the powered device (PD). It’s typically used for powering low-power devices such as VoIP phones, basic IP cameras, and lower-powered access points.

 

Type 2 PoE (IEEE 802.3at)

Type 2 PoE, commonly referred to as PoE+ or IEEE 802.3at, offers a higher power level than Type 1. It can deliver a maximum of 30W per port, with approximately 25.5W available at the PD after accounting for power loss in the cable. This type is suitable for devices that require more power than Type 1 can offer, such as advanced IP cameras, video-conferencing equipment, and high-performance wireless access points.

 

Type 3 PoE (4PPoE – Four-Pair PoE)

Type 3 PoE, also known as 4PPoE (Four-Pair Power over Ethernet) or IEEE 802.3bt, uses all four pairs of the Ethernet cable to deliver power, effectively doubling the power capacity of Type 2. With a maximum power output of 60W per port (approximately 51W available at the PD), Type 3 PoE can power more demanding devices such as pan-tilt-zoom (PTZ) cameras, video phones, or compact switches.

 

Type 4 PoE (Higher Power 4PPoE)

Type 4 PoE is the highest power PoE standard. Also referred to as Higher Power 4PPoE or IEEE 802.3bt, it can deliver up to 90W of power per port (approximately 71W available at the PD). This type is designed to power highly demanding devices, including laptops, digital signage displays, and high-performance wireless access points.

 

In conclusion, each PoE type caters to different power requirements of network devices. Therefore, understanding these types and their capacities is critical for selecting the appropriate PoE equipment and designing efficient and effective PoE networks.

Explaining PoE Types (Type 1, Type 2, Type 3, Type 4)
Explaining PoE Types (Type 1, Type 2, Type 3, Type 4)

Comparing PoE Standards (802.3af, 802.3at, 802.3bt)

Power over Ethernet (PoE) technology has revolutionized the way networked devices are powered and connected, offering the convenience of a single cable for both power and data. Over time, this technology has evolved, culminating in three primary standards: IEEE 802.3af, IEEE 802.3at, and IEEE 802.3bt. Each standard differs primarily in the amount of power they can deliver, and understanding these differences is crucial when choosing the right PoE solution for specific applications.

 

IEEE 802.3af (PoE)

The IEEE 802.3af, also known as PoE, is the original standard that provides up to 15.4W of DC power on each port. However, due to power dissipation, only about 12.95W is guaranteed to be available at the device end. This standard is suitable for powering low-power devices such as primary IP cameras, VoIP phones, and lower-powered access points.

 

IEEE 802.3at (PoE+)

The IEEE 802.3at, commonly referred to as PoE+, is an updated standard that can deliver up to 30W of power per port. After accounting for the power loss in the cable, approximately 25.5W is available at the device end. This increased power capacity makes PoE+ suitable for devices that require more power than the original PoE standard can offer, such as advanced IP cameras, video-conferencing equipment, and high-performance wireless access points.

 

IEEE 802.3bt (PoE++)

The IEEE 802.3bt, also known as PoE++, is the latest standard that significantly increases the power delivery to a maximum of 90W. After considering power loss in the cable, approximately 71W is available at the device end. This high-power delivery makes PoE++ ideal for highly demanding devices, including laptops, digital signage displays, and high-performance wireless access points.

 

In conclusion, while all three standards deliver both power and data over a single cable, they differ in their power capacities. Therefore, the choice of standard depends on the power requirements of the devices in the network. It’s also worth noting that these standards are not mutually exclusive and can coexist in the same network, providing flexibility in meeting varied power demands.

 

Differences in Power Levels

The power levels for each PoE type are determined by their respective standards. Type 1 delivers up to 15.4W, which is suitable for devices like basic IP phones and access points. Type 2 provides up to 30W, enough for advanced IP cameras and video conferencing equipment. Type 3 offers up to 60W, perfect for PTZ cameras and multichannel wireless access points. Lastly, Type 4 delivers up to 90W, which is sufficient for devices such as digital signage and high-performance wireless access points.

 

Power Levels for Different PoE Applications (Security, IoT, VoIP, etc.)

The power level required depends on the application. Security cameras typically need between 15W to 30W, while IoT devices can operate on as low as 15W. VoIP phones usually require around 15W, but advanced models may need more. High-performance wireless access points and digital signage may require up to 90W.

 

Considerations for Cable Selection in PoE

When selecting cables for PoE applications, several factors should be considered. The cable category, length, and quality can all impact the power transmission efficiency. Higher-category cables are often better suited for higher power levels and longer distances, while high-quality cables ensure minimal power loss during transmission. It’s also important to consider the environment where the cables will be installed, as certain conditions may require shielded or outdoor-rated cables.

 

Understanding Power Levels and Capacities in PoE

Power over Ethernet (PoE) technology provides both data connection and electrical power to devices over a single Ethernet cable. A key aspect of understanding this technology is the comprehension of its power levels and capacities. These parameters influence the performance and effectiveness of PoE networks and are critical in planning and deploying such networks. This discussion will delve into the intricacies of PoE power levels, power budgeting, the roles of Power Supply Equipment (PSE) and Powered Devices (PD), data transmission, and how to overcome power loss challenges.

 

Exploring Power over Ethernet Power Levels

In PoE technology, power levels vary significantly depending on the type and standard of PoE being used. For instance, Type 1 PoE (IEEE 802.3af) can deliver up to 15.4W, while Type 2 PoE+ (IEEE 802.3at) supports up to 30W. The more recent Type 3 and Type 4 standards, under IEEE 802.3bt, can deliver up to 60W and 90W, respectively. These different power levels cater to the varying power requirements of other devices.

 

Power Budgeting in PoE Networks

Power budgeting is an essential aspect of PoE network planning. It involves calculating the total power required by all PDs on the network and ensuring the PSE can supply this power. This calculation must consider each device’s maximum power consumption and the total number of devices. If the total power demand exceeds the PSE’s capacity, additional PSEs may be needed, or less power-consuming devices should be considered.

 

Power Supply Equipment (PSE) and Powered Devices (PD)

In a PoE setup, the PSE is the device that provides power on the Ethernet cable, such as a PoE-enabled switch or injector. The PD, on the other hand, is the device receiving power from the PSE, like an IP camera or VoIP phone. The PSE and PD communicate to establish the power level required by the PD, ensuring the PD receives the necessary power for operation.

 

PoE and Data Transmission

PoE technology allows for the concurrent transmission of data and power over the same Ethernet cable. The data is transmitted using the standard Ethernet protocol, while the power is supplied over the same cable but using a different set of wires (for 802.3af/at) or all wires (for 802.3bt). This simultaneous transmission enables the operation of devices at remote locations without a separate power source.

 

Overcoming Power Loss Challenges in PoE

Power loss is a challenge in PoE networks, particularly over long cable distances. To mitigate this, high-quality, higher-category cables can be used as they offer better power transmission efficiency. Additionally, for distances beyond the standard 100 meters, PoE extenders can be employed to boost the signal and ensure adequate power supply. Regular network audits and maintenance can also help identify and rectify power loss issues promptly.

Understanding Power Levels and Capacities in PoE
Understanding Power Levels and Capacities in PoE

Comparing PoE Devices and Components

Power over Ethernet (PoE) technology has given rise to a plethora of devices and components designed to simplify network installations and empower the deployment of networked devices. These components, including PoE injectors, splitters, switches, media converters, extenders, and power supplies, play distinct roles in PoE networks. Understanding their functionalities and differences is crucial for network administrators and IT professionals when designing and deploying PoE networks.

 

Comparison of PoE Injectors and PoE Splitters

A PoE injector is a device that adds power to an Ethernet cable, enabling the delivery of both data and power to a networked device. On the other hand, a PoE splitter separates power from data at the receiving end, which is useful for non-PoE devices. While injectors and splitters essentially serve opposite functions, they often work together in a PoE setup to enable the use of non-PoE devices.

 

PoE Switches vs. PoE Media Converters

PoE switches and media converters are both critical components in a PoE network. A PoE switch acts as a central hub, providing network connectivity and power to multiple devices. A PoE media converter, however, serves a different purpose. It converts one type of media, signal, or format to another, such as from copper to fiber, while also injecting power into the cable. The choice between the two depends on the specific requirements of the network.

 

Selection Criteria for PoE Extenders and Media Converters

When selecting PoE extenders and media converters, several considerations come into play. For extenders, factors include the required extension distance, power budget, environmental conditions, and compatibility with existing network equipment. For media converters, considerations include the types of media being converted, power requirements, network speed, and redundancy requirements.

 

Understanding Ethernet Switches and PoE Power Supply

An Ethernet switch is a networking device that connects multiple devices, like computers and printers, within a network. A PoE power supply, on the other hand, is a device or a feature of a device, like a PoE switch or injector, that supplies power over Ethernet. It’s important to understand that while all PoE switches are Ethernet switches, not all Ethernet switches have PoE power supply capabilities.

 

Power Requirements for Different PoE Applications

Different PoE applications have varying power requirements. For example, a primary IP camera may require only around 15W, while advanced surveillance systems may need up to 30W. High-performance wireless access points and digital signage may require up to 60W or 90W. Understanding these requirements is crucial when planning a PoE network to ensure that the power supply equipment can meet the power demand.

 

Applications and Benefits of Different PoE Power Levels

Power over Ethernet (PoE) technology has revolutionized the networking landscape by delivering power and data over a single Ethernet cable. An essential aspect of PoE is its variable power levels, which cater to a wide range of applications and offer numerous benefits. Whether it’s high-power PoE for demanding applications or low-power PoE for energy-efficient devices, understanding the applications and benefits of different PoE power levels helps network administrators optimize their network performance and efficiency.

 

Utilizing High-Power PoE for Demanding Applications

High-power PoE, delivered via standards like IEEE 802.3bt (Type 3 and Type 4), offers power levels up to 60W and 90W, respectively. This power capacity is essential for demanding applications such as high-performance wireless access points, advanced surveillance systems, and digital signage. By delivering higher power levels, these networks can support more powerful devices without the need for separate power sources.

 

Benefits of Low-Power PoE in Energy-Efficient Devices

On the other end of the spectrum, low-power PoE, provided by standards like IEEE 802.3af (Type 1), delivers power levels up to 15.4W. This is ideal for energy-efficient devices, such as basic IP cameras, VoIP phones, and IoT devices. Low-power PoE not only reduces energy consumption but also minimizes heat generation, contributing to a greener and more cost-effective network infrastructure.

 

Maximizing Power Budget for Large-Scale PoE Networks

In large-scale PoE networks, maximizing the power budget is crucial. This involves careful planning to ensure that the total power demand of all powered devices (PDs) does not exceed the power supply equipment’s (PSE’s) capacity. By selecting the appropriate PoE power levels for each device, network administrators can optimize the power budget, ensuring efficient operation of the network without overloading the PSE.

 

Enhancing Network Flexibility with Variable Power Levels

One of the critical benefits of PoE is the flexibility it offers through variable power levels. Depending on the power requirements of the PD, network administrators can choose from different PoE types and standards. This flexibility allows for a customized network setup that caters to the specific needs of each device, enhancing the overall efficiency and performance of the network.

 

Future Trends in PoE Power Levels and Standards

As networked devices continue to evolve, so too do PoE power levels and standards. The ongoing development of higher power PoE standards is expected to support even more power-hungry devices in the future. Furthermore, advancements in energy-efficient technologies may also lead to more effective low-power PoE solutions. Staying abreast of these trends will enable network administrators to future-proof their networks and harness the full potential of PoE technology.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

——

Q: What is the Power over Ethernet (PoE) in networking?

A: Power over Ethernet (PoE) signifies a network technology enabling the concurrent transmission of data and electrical power to PoE-compatible devices like IP cameras and network switches via an Ethernet cable.

Q: What is the 802.3bt PoE standard?

A: 802.3bt PoE standard or 4-pair PoE offers the most considerable power capabilities, delivering power through standard Ethernet cables using the cable’s four wire pairs.

Q: How does PoE deliver power and data over Ethernet cable?

A: PoE uses the Ethernet cable’s unutilized wires to supply power to PoE devices, ensuring energy is received without a separate power source.

Q: What is a PoE class, and how does it relate to the type of PoE?

A: The PoE class defines the power capabilities a PoE device can support, with classes varying in power levels. The course correlates with the PoE type as it decides the amount of power deliverable to the connected devices.

Q: What is the difference between PoE Type 1 and PoE Type 2?

A: PoE Type 1 can provide up to 15.4 watts of power, whereas PoE Type 2 can deliver up to 30 watts of power per port, offering enhanced power capacities for PoE-enabled devices.

Q: What are the types of PoE in terms of power delivery?

A: PoE types, including Type 1, Type 2, and Type 4, differ in their power delivery capacities, with each type providing varying power levels to support distinct PoE devices and applications.

Q: What is PoE Type 4, and how does it differ from other PoE types?

A: PoE Type 4, known as the 802.3bt standard, uses the phantom power technique to offer the highest power capabilities, delivering up to 60-100 watts of power over standard Ethernet cables, thus supporting power-demanding devices.

Q: What are the benefits of using PoE for powering devices in a network?

A: PoE negates the requirement for separate AC power outlets near devices, simplifies installation, and enables the setup of remote PoE devices disconnected from AC power, providing flexibility and convenience in powering network devices.

Q: Which types of devices can benefit from PoE for power delivery?

A: A variety of devices, such as IP phones, security cameras, wireless access points, and IoT devices, can utilize PoE for power delivery, operating without a nearby power source requirement.

Q: What are the key features of the 802.3bt PoE standard?

A: The 802.3bt PoE standard, or Type 4 PoE, provides the most substantial power capabilities, delivering up to 60-100 watts of power per port, making it ideal for powering high-power devices over standard Ethernet networks.

References

——

  1. The Demonstration of Power over Ethernet (PoE) Technologies in Commercial and Institutional Buildings This source provides insights into the application of PoE technologies in commercial and institutional buildings. It offers a comparison of effective power at different lighting levels in a PoE system, which is crucial for understanding the power capacities of different PoE standards.
  2. The Demonstration of Power over Ethernet (PoE) Technologies in Commercial and Institutional Buildings This document offers an overview of the history of PoE standards and their applications in lighting systems. It provides valuable information on how to compare the energy use of PoE lights against a base case, contributing to a more profound understanding of PoE power efficiency.
  3. Beyond Power over Ethernet: The Development of Digital Energy Networks for Buildings This article discusses the development of digital energy networks for buildings, focusing on the evolution of PoE standards. It provides a comparison between different systems, helping readers understand the importance of building cross-industry networks.
  4. Advanced Four-Pair Architecture with Input Current Balance Function for Power over Ethernet (PoE) System This academic paper offers a deep dive into the technical aspects of PoE systems, particularly focusing on four-pair architecture. It not only improves the power level but also achieves a balanced input current, which is key in comparing different PoE standards.
  5. PoE Lighting System Energy Reporting Study, Part 1 This study focuses on the energy performance of PoE lighting systems. It provides insights into how PoE systems compare with other energy performance standards, offering a deeper understanding of the efficiency of different PoE standards.
  6. Power-over-Ethernet for Avionic Networks This paper discusses the application of PoE in avionic networks. It provides a comparison between PoE and legacy aeronautic protocols, helping readers understand the benefits of PoE standards in this specific industry.
  7. Scalable Smart Transducers Network Using Power-over-Ethernet: Towards Smarter, Safer and More Controllable Buildings This source explores the use of PoE in smart transducers networks. It compares the improvements in power supply and data transmission via PoE standards, providing insights into the scalability and controllability of PoE networks.
  8. SpaceWire Communications in Power over Ethernet Environment This article delves into the application of PoE in SpaceWire communications. It provides a comparison of PoE with standard Ethernet, contributing to a broader understanding of the effectiveness of PoE standards in different communication environments.
  9. Audio Amplifier Powered over Ethernet A Study of Using IEEE 802.3 at Power over Ethernet as a Power Source for a Class-D Audio Amplifier This study focuses on using PoE as a power source for a class-D audio amplifier. It compares the impact of PoE on the audio amplifier’s performance, helping readers understand the practical applications of PoE standards in audio devices.
  10. SpaceWire Communications in Power over Ethernet Environment This source provides further insights into the application of PoE in SpaceWire communications. It offers a comparison of PoE with standard Ethernet, contributing to a deeper understanding of the readiness level of the SpaceWire over PoE technology.